MIGHTY® PLUSH DOG TOYS

Meet Your Dog’s Next Favorite

From playful animals to seasonal characters, discover plush toys for fetching, tossing, and carrying—and personalities as big as your dog’s.

Shop Mighty Toys →
Mix & match Tuffy®, Mighty® & DuraForce®. Get the second toy of equal or lesser value 30% off. No code needed.
72 products
A plush goat-shaped dog toy with a white body, brown horns, and embroidered eyes. Designed for durable play.
Mighty® Farm Goat Dog Toy from $1199
The image shows a plush toy designed to look like Santa Claus. The toy is dressed in a traditional Santa outfit, which includes a red suit with white trim, a black belt, black boots, and a red hat with white trim. Santa has a long white beard and is depicted holding a white sack over his shoulder. The toy appears to be made of soft, fluffy material, making it suitable for cuddling or as a decorative item
The image shows the back view of the same plush toy Santa Claus. The toy is dressed in a red suit with white trim, black boots, and a red hat with a white pom-pom. Santa is depicted holding a white sack over his shoulder, and you can see the details of the back of his suit and boots. The toy appears to be made of soft, plush material, with the white trim being fluffy and the red suit having a quilted pattern.
Mighty® Arctic Santa Dog Toy $1799
Two red rabbit-shaped plush dog toys with quilted fabric, white ear and tail accents, and open mouths showing playful sharp teeth.
A red rabbit-shaped plush dog toy with quilted fabric, white ear and tail accents, and an open mouth showing playful sharp teeth.
Mighty® Angry Animal™ Series - Rabbit from $1499
Black skeleton plush dog toy with a white face on a white background
Black and white skeleton plush dog toy on a white background
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Skeleton Dog Toy $2499
A plush dog toy shaped like a fantasy elf character, featuring a green shaggy hat, brown shaggy beard, red shaggy pants and headband, green shaggy tunic, black belt, and yellow buckle, on a plain white background.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Elf Dog Toy $2499
Plush toy raccoon on a white background
Plush toy raccoon on a white background
Mighty® Nature Raccoon Dog Toy from $1299
Mighty® Safari Monkey Dog Toy $1199
Two brown plush dogs with white accents on a white background
Plush pug dog toy in light brown with black snout and white belly, soft stuffed toy for dogs of all sizes.
Mighty® Farm Pug Dog Toy from $1599
A green plush lizard dog toy standing upright, showing its orange feet and soft microfiber exterior, with a bright green fringe along its back.
Mighty® Microfiber Lizard Dog Toy from $1699
Green plush triceratops dog toy with soft microfiber texture and gray horns, ideal for gentle play
Plush triceratops dog toy in playful bow position, made with soft microfiber for dogs who love to snuggle and shake toys
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Triceratops Dog Toy $2499
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Pig Dog Toy from $1699
A front view of the black plush penguin toy, featuring a white belly, orange feet and beak, and large embroidered eyes.
A rear view of a black plush penguin-shaped dog toy with shaggy microfiber material and orange feet.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Penguin Dog Toy – Black $2499
A red plush toy shaped like a skeleton with black heart-shaped eyes and a stitched mouth, made from microfiber material.
A side view of the red skeleton plush toy, highlighting its stitched mouth, heart-shaped eyes, and fluffy microfiber body.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Grim Reaper Dog Toy $2499
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Blowfish Dog Toy $1699
Yellow plush dragon-shaped dog toy with a textured body, white belly, black wings, and embroidered eyes, designed for interactive play.
Yellow plush dragon-shaped dog toy with a textured body, white belly, black wings, and multiple squeakers, designed for interactive play. Machine washable and floats.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Dragon – Yellow Dog Toy $2499
Two plush giraffe toys on a white background
Mighty® Micro Ball Giraffe Dog Toy: Plush giraffe-shaped toy with a fuzzy yellow body, orange spots, brown ossicones, and black embroidered eyes. Soft and playful.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Giraffe Dog Toy from $1699
Red Mighty® Bone dog toy with hamburger pattern, durable and soft, machine washable, floats, no stuffing, features a tough core and safe squeaker pockets.
Yellow Mighty® Bone dog toy with unicorn and farting rainbow pattern, durable and soft, machine washable, floats, no stuffing, features a tough core and safe squeaker pockets.
+1
Mighty® Bone Dog Toy $1499
A purple plush hippo toy with a diamond-quilted texture and bright green accents on its mouth, ears, and belly, shown against a plain white background.
Mighty® Safari Hippo Junior plush dog toy in purple with lime green ear and chin accents on a white background.
Mighty® Safari Hippo Plush Dog Toy from $1299
Mighty® Nature Duck Plush Dog Toy from $1299
Pink plush toy resembling a pig on a white background
Mighty® Angry Pig Dog Toy from $1411
Plush toy resembling a witch with green face, black hat, and black outfit on a white background
Witch-themed plush toy with a packaging label for Mighty Dog Toys on a white background
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Witch Dog Toy $2499
Mighty® Holiday Small Pumpkin Ball Dog Toy $899
A plush cow toy with a wide open grin showing white teeth and pink gums, black-and-white spotted fur, small gray horns, and raised paws, isolated on a white background.
A plush cow toy with a black and white spotted body, gray horns, and a large pink mouth showing white teeth, photographed on a plain white background.
Mighty® Angry Animal Series – Cow from $1299
A black cat-shaped plush toy with bright yellow ears, eyes, nose, and paw pads, sitting against a plain white background.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Med Cat Dog Toy $2499
Mighty® Arctic Narwhal Dog Toy from $1099
Mighty® Liar Pegasus Dog Toy from $1499
Yellow plush seahorse toy on a white background
Mighty® Ocean Seahorse Dog Toy from $1199
Mighty Safari Giraffe plush dog toys in two sizes – durable stuffed animal toy for dogs
Safari-themed giraffe plush dog toy with spotted pattern – tough dog toy for interactive play
Mighty® Safari Brown Giraffe Dog Toy from $1199
A red plush dinosaur-shaped dog toy with a shaggy microfiber texture and small grey plates along its back.
A rear-side view of the red dinosaur plush dog toy, featuring its plush grey back plates and soft, fluffy body.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Stegosaurus Dog Toy $2499
A colorful plush penguin-shaped dog toy with a red body, yellow beak and feet, and a white belly, made of soft microfiber material.
A front view of the red plush penguin dog toy, emphasizing its shaggy microfiber texture and playful design with large eyes and a yellow beak.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Penguin Dog Toy – Red $1359
Plush toy resembling a monster with green face and black body on a white background
Side view of a Frankenstein-themed plush dog toy with a green face, stitched facial details, and a soft black microfiber body.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Frankenstein Dog Toy $2499
Side view of a purple plush dragon-shaped dog toy with a textured body, orange belly and spine, white horns, and wings, designed for interactive play.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Dragon – Purple Dog Toy $2499
1 2
Recently viewed

Let customers speak for us

from 169 reviews

Great product.

Michael McQuaid
Goughnuts Original Tug Dog Toy - Orange, Medium

Fast service

dianne gleich

This ball is awesome! My dog chews up everything he gets and he has not put even a tooth Mark in this one yet and he loves the way it bounces when you throw it and it hits the end and bounces up and down oh my gosh this ball is great!

dianne gleich
Ruff Dawg Football XL Dog Toy - Lifetime Guaranteed

Inola had a larger version of this one but unfortunately her toys don’t last forever. She really likes tossing it up in the air when she plays by herself.

Anonymous
Multipet Minipet Plush Monsters Dog Toy – 5"

Was impressed with the quick delivery and personal thank you note.

Anonymous

Inola loves to play fetch with this one.

Anonymous
Multipet Minipet Plush Monsters Dog Toy – 5"

Much bigger than I thought, which is nice for once w/ dog toys. Quality is top-notch.

Jason
Tuffy® Barnyard Talulah Turkey Dog Toy

It too is great - just a bit too big for his mouth - soon - lol

Mary
Multipet Theo TPR Squeaky Ball Dog Toy – 3"

It is really nice - but my beagle pup is only 9 wks old & hasn’t gotten the squeak thing yet .

Mary
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Monster Dog Toy

A great selection of dog toys.

Cindy Brown

My dog loves her Lamb Chop.

Cindy Brown
Multipet Lamb Chop® Plush Dog Toy – 10"

Great toy, my dog loves all the squeakers.

Cindy Brown
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Rabbit Dog Toy

Fast shipping and easy checkout.

Cindy Brown

Very durable my Malinois hasn't destroyed it.

Cindy Brown
Ruff Dawg Big Dawg Dog Toy - Lifetime Guaranteed

Great toy!

Cindy Brown
Tuffy® Holiday Santa Plush Dog Toy