MIGHTY® PLUSH DOG TOYS

Meet Your Dog’s Next Favorite

From playful animals to seasonal characters, discover plush toys for fetching, tossing, and carrying—and personalities as big as your dog’s.

Shop Mighty Toys →
Mix & match Tuffy®, Mighty® & DuraForce®. Get the second toy of equal or lesser value 30% off. No code needed.
72 products
A bright blue, plush monster-shaped dog toy with a shaggy microfiber texture and large googly eyes.
A side view of the blue plush monster toy, highlighting its fluffy body and standing posture, with its large eyes looking forward.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Monster Dog Toy from $1699
Mighty Micro Ball Bear Dog Toy: Plush bear-shaped toy with a fuzzy blue body, brown nose, black embroidered eyes, and tan paw pads with black paw prints. Soft and playful.
Mighty® Micro Ball Bear Dog Toy: Side view of a plush bear-shaped toy with a fuzzy blue body, brown nose, black embroidered eyes, and tan paw pads with black paw prints. Soft and playful.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Bear Dog Toy $2499
A bright orange plush dinosaur-shaped dog toy with shaggy microfiber texture, small arms, and a wide open mouth with white teeth.
A side view of the orange plush dinosaur dog toy, highlighting its fluffy microfiber material and toothy grin.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball T-Rex Dog Toy $2499
Three sizes of brown plush monkey dog toys made with durable microfiber for dogs of all sizes.
Brown and tan microfiber monkey dog toy with textured shaggy surface, ideal for small to medium dogs.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Monkey Dog Toy from $1699
Plush gingerbread man toy with a Santa hat on a white background
Side view of a gingerbread man plush dog toy, featuring a Santa hat, green buttons, and white accents on the arms, with a soft microfiber texture.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Gingerbread Man Dog Toy $2499
Two plush toys, one pink and green, the other brown, on a white background.
Mighty® Safari Warthog Dog Toy $2599
Three yellow plush ducks with orange beaks and feet on a white background
Large microfiber duck dog toy in yellow and orange, designed for gentle play.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Duck Dog Toy from $1699
Two pink plush pig-shaped dog toys with quilted patterns and angry expressions, one larger and one smaller
Pink plush pig-shaped dog toy with a quilted pattern and an angry expression
Mighty® Angry Animal™ Pig $1499
Two plush cow-shaped dog toys with black spots, wide grins showing large teeth, and udders, featuring comical and exaggerated expressions. One is larger and one is smaller
Cow-shaped dog toy with black and white plush body, wide eyes, a large grinning mouth with big teeth, and udder detail. Designed for fun interactive play.
Mighty® Angry Animal™ Series - Cow $1699
Pair of blue fantasy dragon dog toys with horns and wings on plain background
Dragon deep blue dog toy designed for interactive and fetch play, made from durable, pet-safe materials
Mighty® Dragon Blue Dog Toy from $1299
Two plush penguin-shaped dog toys, one larger and one smaller. Both have black backs, heads, and wings, white bellies, and yellow beaks and feet. The toys feature embroidered eye details and are designed for durable, interactive play.
Side profile of Mighty Arctic Penguin dog toy showing detailed black plush back, flipper, and bright yellow feet.
Mighty® Arctic Penguin Dog Toy from $1199
Plush dog toy shaped like a bee with a fuzzy yellow and black striped body, large white eyes with orange pupils, black legs, and white wings.
A plush bee toy with a fuzzy yellow and black body, white wings, and black legs, shown on a plain white background.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Bee Dog Toy $2499
Two plush bear-shaped dog toys with brown fur, open mouths showing teeth, and raised paws, one larger and one smaller.
Front view of plush grizzly bear dog toy with open mouth and raised paws, ultra-durable design for tough chewers.
Mighty® Angry Animal™Series - Bear from $1599
Three plush dog toy rabbit animals on a white background
Plush toy resembling a rabbit on a white background
Mighty® Nature Brown Rabbit Dog Toy from $1199
Three toy goldfish on a white background
Single plush goldfish dog toy in yellow with bright orange fins, soft and squeaky for dogs.
Mighty® Ocean Goldfish Dog Toy from $1199
Two plush orange bull-shaped dog toys with horns and wide eyes, displayed on a white background—available in large and small sizes.
Front view of orange microfiber bull-shaped dog toy with oversized eyes, brown horns, and tan snout
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Orange Bull Dog Toy from $1699
A red plush dog toy with large white and black eyes, featuring a textured, shaggy surface and designed for interactive play.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Lobster Dog Toy from $1299
Two purple plush toys with brown accents on a white background
A purple plush dog toy with a microfiber texture, large cartoon-like eyes, and yellow textured ears.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Elephant Dog Toy from $1699
A green plush turtle dog toy with a brown textured shell, showing its soft microfiber material and stitched eyes.
A side view of the green plush turtle dog toy, highlighting its brown shell and fuzzy microfiber surface.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Turtle Dog Toy – Green $2499
The image shows the front view of the MIGHTY® Dog Toy called "Microfiber Ball Pumpkin Man." The toy is bright orange with a fuzzy texture and is designed to resemble a jack-o'-lantern. It has a round head with a green stem on top, a black smiling jack-o'-lantern face, and triangular black patches on its body, enhancing the pumpkin theme. The toy is soft, minimally stuffed, and crafted for interactive play with dogs.
The image displays a side view of the MIGHTY® Dog Toy called "Microfiber Ball Pumpkin Man." The toy, which is bright orange and fuzzy, resembles a pumpkin with a jack-o'-lantern face. From this angle, the green stem on top is visible, along with the toy's round head, arms, and legs. The black triangular patches on the body are also partially visible. The toy's soft texture and minimal stuffing make it suitable for interactive play with dogs.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Pumpkin Man Dog Toy $2499
Two angles of the yellow and red plush dragon dog toy showing detailed face, long coiled tail, and soft fabric texture.
Bright yellow and red dragon plush dog toy with exaggerated facial features, coiled body, and fuzzy accents, shown on white background.
Mighty® Dragon Yellow Dog Toy from $1399
Two red dragon plush dog toys with black spikes and beige bellies, showing different angles of the toy design.
Red dragon plush dog toy with black horns and stitched wings, shown on white background.
Mighty® Dragon Red Dog Toy from $1299
Plush reindeer toy with black antlers and a red nose on a white background
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Reindeer Dog Toy $2499
Three plush panda dog toys in small, medium, and large sizes, ideal for gentle chewers and cuddle play – soft black and white stuffed animal design.
A black and white plush panda-shaped dog toy with soft, shaggy microfiber texture and a cute, friendly expression.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Panda Dog Toy from $1699
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Dragon – Red Dog Toy $2499
Two plush bee dog toys in different sizes, showcasing large and small variants with bold black-and-yellow design and floppy wings.
Front view of large plush bee dog toy with oversized eyes and white wings, designed for interactive dog play.
Mighty® Bug Bee Dog Toy from $1199
Two plush dog toys from the MIGHTY Microfiber JR collection, one red and one blue, with soft, textured microfiber material and large cartoon-like eyes.
MIGHTY Microfiber Ball Toy with squeaker balls, minimal stuffing, soft microfiber exterior, machine washable, and floats in water.
Mighty® Jr. Microfiber Ball Monster & Elephant 2 Pack $3099
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Snowman Dog Toy $2499
Two pink plush bunnies on a white background
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Rabbit Dog Toy from $1699
Plush monkey-shaped dog toy with an angry expression, standing upright with arms raised above its head.
Two plush monkey-shaped dog toys with angry expressions, standing upright with arms raised above their heads, one larger and one smaller
Mighty Angry Animal Series - Monkey from $1499
Mighty® Ocean Hammerhead Dog Toy from $1199
Mighty® Liar Unicorn Dog Toy from $1499
Two plush dinosaur toys, one larger and one smaller, on a white background.
Plush dinosaur toy with a pink mouth on a white background
Mighty® Dinosaur T-Rex Dog Toy from $1299
Two sizes of brown plush dinosaur dog toys with bright orange spikes, side-by-side for size comparison.
Plush dinosaur dog toy with orange fabric spikes on brown textured body, shown on white background.
Mighty® Dinosaur Stegosaurus Dog Toy from $1299
Bright green dragon-shaped plush dog toy with red mouth, yellow wings, and textured scales, designed for interactive play.
Green dragon plush dog toy with yellow belly, brown horns, and open red mouth, shown on white background.
Mighty® Dragon Dog Toy – Green from $1299
Two sizes of Mighty® Safari Pink Giraffe plush dog toys shown side by side.
Pink plush giraffe dog toy with black hooves and fun print design—extra-large soft toy perfect for cuddling or gentle indoor play.
Mighty® Safari Pink Giraffe Dog Toy from $1199
Mighty® Safari Orange Elephant Dog Toy from $1199
Three plush toy leopards of different sizes on a white background
Plush leopard toy with soft, spotted fur, lying in a stretched-out position.
Mighty® Safari Leopard Dog Toy from $1199
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Santa Dog Toy $2499
Plush toy bat with purple body and black wings on a white background
A front view of the black and purple bat plush toy, showcasing its large black wings and textured purple body.
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Purple Bat (Halloween) Dog Toy $2499
1 2
Recently viewed

Let customers speak for us

from 169 reviews

Great product.

Michael McQuaid
Goughnuts Original Tug Dog Toy - Orange, Medium

Fast service

dianne gleich

This ball is awesome! My dog chews up everything he gets and he has not put even a tooth Mark in this one yet and he loves the way it bounces when you throw it and it hits the end and bounces up and down oh my gosh this ball is great!

dianne gleich
Ruff Dawg Football XL Dog Toy - Lifetime Guaranteed

Inola had a larger version of this one but unfortunately her toys don’t last forever. She really likes tossing it up in the air when she plays by herself.

Anonymous
Multipet Minipet Plush Monsters Dog Toy – 5"

Was impressed with the quick delivery and personal thank you note.

Anonymous

Inola loves to play fetch with this one.

Anonymous
Multipet Minipet Plush Monsters Dog Toy – 5"

Much bigger than I thought, which is nice for once w/ dog toys. Quality is top-notch.

Jason
Tuffy® Barnyard Talulah Turkey Dog Toy

It too is great - just a bit too big for his mouth - soon - lol

Mary
Multipet Theo TPR Squeaky Ball Dog Toy – 3"

It is really nice - but my beagle pup is only 9 wks old & hasn’t gotten the squeak thing yet .

Mary
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Monster Dog Toy

A great selection of dog toys.

Cindy Brown

My dog loves her Lamb Chop.

Cindy Brown
Multipet Lamb Chop® Plush Dog Toy – 10"

Great toy, my dog loves all the squeakers.

Cindy Brown
Mighty® Microfiber Ball Rabbit Dog Toy

Fast shipping and easy checkout.

Cindy Brown

Very durable my Malinois hasn't destroyed it.

Cindy Brown
Ruff Dawg Big Dawg Dog Toy - Lifetime Guaranteed

Great toy!

Cindy Brown
Tuffy® Holiday Santa Plush Dog Toy